When valuing a property, the most recent sale is not necessarily the most useful. Although recent transactions help establish current market conditions, an older sale may sometimes provide a better comparison.
The important question is not simply when a property sold, but how closely it compares with the property being valued.
What makes a good comparable?
Two properties may have sold within weeks of each other but differ considerably in location, size, design, condition or market appeal.
A recent sale may appear relevant at first, but if substantial adjustments are needed to account for these differences, its usefulness becomes limited.
An older sale, on the other hand, may involve a property in the same neighbourhood, sectional-title scheme or industrial park. It may be very similar in size, accommodation, construction and condition.
In such cases, the older transaction may provide more reliable evidence, provided that changes in market conditions since the sale can be reasonably established.
Time is only one consideration
A valuer considers several factors when selecting comparable sales. These include location, property type, size, accommodation, condition, permitted use, market appeal and the circumstances of the transaction.
The date of sale is important, but it should not outweigh all the other considerations.
A recent sale requiring several uncertain adjustments may be less useful than an older, closely matched transaction requiring mainly an adjustment for market movement.
What older sales can tell us
In areas where properties change hands infrequently, older transactions can be particularly useful.
Several reasonably comparable sales over a longer period may reveal a clearer market pattern than one isolated recent transaction.
They may also help explain whether a recent selling price reflects a genuine change in market conditions or an unusual circumstance, such as financial pressure, special purchaser motivation or limited market exposure.
This is especially relevant to specialised properties, where directly comparable sales may be few and far between.
Making allowance for market movement
Using an older sale does not mean simply increasing its price by a general inflation percentage.
Market conditions may have improved, weakened or remained relatively unchanged since the transaction. Any adjustment must reflect the relevant property sector and local market.
Where reliable evidence is available, an adjustment for time may be easier to support than several substantial adjustments for differences in location, design or property quality.
However, older sales must still be considered alongside recent transactions, asking prices, marketing activity and prevailing market conditions.
Choosing the most reliable evidence
The selection of comparable sales requires judgement. No two properties are exactly alike, and the available evidence is seldom perfect.
The valuer must consider both recent and older transactions, assess their relevance and explain why certain sales deserve more weight than others.
An older sale should never be preferred simply because it supports a particular valuation figure. Equally, a recent sale should not be given undue weight merely because it is the latest transaction
The most useful comparable is not necessarily the most recent sale. It is the transaction that provides the most reliable evidence of how the market values a property with similar characteristics.
Independent. Methodical. Defensible.
