One Property, Four
Perspectives
The seller remembers a home, the buyer imagines a future, the valuer
examines the evidence, and the bank considers the risk.
The same property can mean something quite different to each party involved in a transaction. Their perspectives are not necessarily in conflict; they simply approach the property with different interests, expectations and responsibilities.
The seller remembers a home
To the seller, a property is seldom just bricks, mortar and land.
It may represent years of hard work, financial sacrifice and treasured
memories. Improvements such as a renovated kitchen, landscaped garden or
entertainment area often reflect considerable planning, personal involvement
and expense.
Understandably, the seller expects these investments to be recognised in
the selling price.
However, the market does not necessarily compensate an owner for money
spent. Buyers consider the usefulness, condition and appeal of improvements
rather than their original cost.
Even good maintenance, while important in preserving value, may be regarded
by buyers as something they should reasonably expect rather than an improvement
deserving an additional premium.
The buyer imagines a future
The buyer approaches the property with different expectations.
Will the house suit the family's needs? Is the location convenient? Does
the layout work? Is it secure, comfortable and affordable?
First impressions matter. Natural light, attractive finishes, a welcoming
entrance or simply the feeling of being at home can influence a purchasing
decision.
The seller's expensive new kitchen may be exactly what one buyer wants,
while another may dislike the design and consider replacing it.
These personal preferences influence purchasing decisions, but their
contribution to Market Value depends on how widely they are shared by other
prospective buyers.
The valuer examines the evidence
The valuer must recognise both the seller's expectations and the buyer's
preferences without being influenced unduly by either.
The task is to determine the property's Market Value at the valuation date,
based on an assessment of the property and supporting market evidence. This
involves examining the property's location, accommodation, condition and
improvements, together with comparable sales and prevailing market conditions.
No two properties are exactly alike, and comparable evidence is seldom
perfect. Professional judgement is required to distinguish between features
that genuinely contribute to Market Value and those reflecting personal taste
or expenditure.
The conclusion may differ from the seller's expectations or the price a
particular buyer is willing to pay.
The valuation must nevertheless remain independent, evidence-based and
defensible.
The bank considers the risk
For the bank, the property represents security for the proposed loan.
While the buyer may willingly pay a premium for a particular location, view
or personal preference, the bank needs to establish whether the agreed price is
supported by the broader market.
An agreed selling price is not necessarily proof of Market Value. It
reflects what a particular buyer and seller have agreed upon, while Market
Value considers what the market as a whole is likely to support.
The bank must also consider the borrower's financial position and ability
to repay the loan. The valuation assists in assessing the security offered but
does not determine the lending decision.
Four perspectives, one property
The seller sees the value of what has been invested, both financially and
personally. The buyer considers the possibilities the property offers.
The valuer examines what the market evidence supports, while the bank
considers whether the property provides adequate security for the proposed
loan.
Each perspective has its place, but they do not necessarily arrive at the
same figure.
One property. Four perspectives. One market reality. 